Finding a “new” Harry Harby picture

Showing how some detective teamwork identified the place and connection of a curious photograph and opened up a soldier’s service story

Bill Pinfold

I had a digital copy of this photograph for some time and, because it came to me along with other pictures of my grandfather William Ernest Pinfold, who served in Mesopotamia in WW1, I assumed it must in some way be connected to him. “Ernie” is not identifiable in the group of men, so might it include some other Pinfold relative?

The photograph in question

It was difficult to identify the place, time or people involved, and a curiosity had been that none of the men are wearing Leicestershire Regiment insignia, whilst I knew Ernie Pinfold and his brother Richard Cecil Pinfold served with the “Tigers”. Their eldest brother Albert also served, but as a Gunner/Driver in the Royal Garrison Artillery. Both Cecil and Albert served in units only based in France, so they would not be in the photo.

Some requests for help at websites covering WW1 campaigns in the Middle East drew a blank. The men in the image looked to be wearing Army Service Corps (ASC) badges (apart from a young lad with a Royal Artillery cap) and the buildings in the background had distinctive open balconies. A man in the background wears Egyptian dress and there is a monkey perched on the knee of the lance corporal seated on a crate. But no one I approached could advise the place or identify the specific army unit.

Then a request came in to BLHS from a serving army officer commanding a Medical Squadron in the current army, asking permission to show a picture at his barracks history room of Harry Harby when he served with the 35th Field Ambulance in WW1, that unit being a direct antecedent of the modern squadron. This proved to be the catalyst to finding the key information about my unidentified photograph. Rather than being from the Pinfold side of my family, might it be from the Harby line, as Ernie’s wife, my grandmother, was Nellie Harby.

Her eldest brother Harry Harby, of Butcher’s Row, is already mentioned in several articles that we have on the BLHS web site, including his posting to Gallipoli in 1915 with the ASC and the postcards that he sent home when subsequently based in Egypt and then France. Here was a good candidate for a link with the photograph – why hadn’t I thought of that before. Doh!

Harry Harby in England (Left, Centre) and in Egypt (Right)

Comparing the known face of Harry Harby from a photograph in the collection of Glenys Claricoats (see this link), one man in the photograph is surely a close resemblance: the man standing on the left with a cooking pan dangling from his hand. The moustache has got longer and a bit ragged, but the eyebrows, ears, jawline etc are the same. The image of the men and monkey looks to be Harry with a group of his fellow ASC drivers having a brew or meal at a town, presumably in Egypt, probably in 1916 after they had left Gallipoli.

So where was the location? The details in the background provide some clues. There are three sizeable buildings with sloping roofs and open continuous balconies at the first floor level. The buildings are beside a large flat expanse of ground. Over the ridges of the buildings can be seen the tops of sailing ship masts, suggesting that the location is by the water. From this angle of view the masts are very tall and they have cross-spars, so they are ocean going vessels, not just river craft. Also in view over one of the roofs is a tower which looks very much like a church steeple.

Thus I started some “educated guess” searches on Google Streetview and Google Images. Alexandria? No. Port Said? No. Other ports around the Mediterranean coast such as Gibraltar or Malta? No. And it certainly wasn’t in the Dardanelles where the Allied forces never had the luxury of buildings and flat ground on which to pose for such a picture.

Next I checked the collections of battalion War Diaries, some of which are available online, and they showed units of the ASC deployed to units guarding the Suez Canal. I had already found some pages of Harry Harby’s service record on the Find My Past system, so we knew some of his dates of service and that he had shipped to the Middle East with the 49th Reserve Park ASC company. The 49th Reserve Park, were not mentioned in particular in the War Diaries, but perhaps the canal was the water for the ships masts in the photo. So I looked for images of towns along the canal route. Port Fuad; or El Quantara? No.  Ismailia? No.

But in the images search for Ismailia the jackpot suddenly appeared. Port Tewfiq – a postcard image which captures the canal side, a narrow church steeple and a line of buildings with open balconies. This was it.

Port Tewfiq (there are various spellings)

The black and white postcard, from the early 20th century, shows lines of buildings alongside two streets which ran parallel to the Suez Canal, close by its southern entrance. An avenue of trees runs beside the water, shading a street which includes single-storey buildings and a church with a slender spire rising to a tall point. The second street runs between the rear of the single-storey buildings and a row of three two-storey buildings with sloping roofs and open continuous balconies. The fit with the topology of my photograph is exact.

New searches for images of a church in Port Tewfiq have revealed a 1942 US Army map which names the first street as Shari (or Boulevard) St Helene, named for the Roman Catholic church of St Helena which is the base of the elegant spire. The second street was Shari El Kinisa. Hidden from the postcard’s viewpoint, on the other side of the balconied buildings lay a third parallel street, Shari De Lesseps, named for the French diplomat who championed the construction of the canal. The open ground which had been where Harry and his cohort pitched their cooker in 1916 was still shown as level ground in the 1942 map, though railway sidings had been added later across their encampment area.

 

Port Tewfiq. 1942 Map keyed to current satellite view. The photo was taken where the rail lines are shown at the centre of the inset.

RC Church of St Helena

When the Suez Canal first opened in 1869 the land at the southern entrance only had a few shacks on it, but over time trading companies established stone buildings for load handling and the French, British and Egyptian canal owners built offices and accommodation blocks and hence Port Tewfiq became a sizeable town. The canal operated on a one-way convoy system, so vessels had to wait at Port Tewfiq until they could join the next north-bound convoy. Any pious sailors and passengers waiting at Port Tewfiq who sought religious solace were supported by the Anglo-French controlled Suez Canal Company which organised occasional services until, in 1887, the church of St Helena was built and opened with two priests in permanent residence.

Europeans derived various spellings to interpret the local Arabic name, so it is sometimes written Port Tewfik, Teufik, Taufiq or Tewfiek. The town grew over the decades as railway lines and new dockside facilities increased trading capacity. But there was a pause when the Suez crisis led to traffic being suspended for political reasons in the 1950s. The canal had been seen as a strategic asset ever since it opened.

When the Israelis attacked the Sinaii desert in the six day war of 1967 they advanced straight to the line of the canal. The town was ravaged by artillery and gun fire and the buildings along the waterside, including St Helena’s church, were ruined. For the next few years the city was in stasis. The image in the old postcard is unrecognisable today, as modern buildings have been built since the formal cessation of hostilities in the 1990s and Port Tewfiq has been subsumed into the greater Port Suez city.

I still wanted to know what Harry Harby was doing at Port Tewfiq. Had he been attached as an ASC driver to the 35th Field Ambulance by then? For they too had been based in Gallipoli and then had shifted to Egypt when the Turks won the Dardanelles campaign. So I put calls out for guidance and assistance and, with the help in particular of Jonathan D’Hooghe of the Lincolnshire branch of the Western Front Association, who was able to give a more focused insight into the War Diaries than my earlier efforts, a much fuller life story for Harry Harby has now been pieced together.

DATEEVENT
10 Feb 1883Harry Harby born at Pickworth, Lincs. He was baptised on the 18 March at St Andrews church.
1901Worked as a horse waggoner on a farm in Croxton Kerrial, Leics. The census listed his age as 19 though he was only 18 years and 1 month at the time. Nearby, at The Nook in the same village one of the general house servants was 23 year old Rose Taylor, originally from Easthorpe, Bottesford, Leics.
1 Jun 1903Harry Harby and Rose Taylor married at Bottesford on Monday 1 June 1903, the banns having been read over the previous three Sundays. They lived at Butcher’s Row cottages on the High Street.
14 May 1904Daughter Florence Edith Harby born at Grantham.
Before 1911Joined GNR as a platelayer.
16 Nov 1912Joined a union (Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants)
23 Feb 1915Enlisted at Newark. Assigned to the Army Service Corps with number T4/061462.
24 Feb 1915Joined up at Bradford and started basic training.
Assigned as a horse transport driver with 49th Reserve Park, an ASC company which provides “Lines of Communication”, i.e. transport of supplies and fodder to different units.
16 Apr 1915Unit departed for Middle East
27 Apr 1915Arrived Alexandria
Circa 2 May 1915Departed for Gallipoli
25 Sep 1915Grantham Journal reports a letter home from Harry. See more at this link.
December 1915It is impossible to say exactly which day Harry Harby was evacuated from Gallipoli as  ASC Drivers were moving troops, supplies, medical units and other resources to the departure beaches every day through December. He is likely to have departed before 19 Dec. Return to Egypt via at least one stop at a Greek island, probably Mudros/Lemnos.
From the photograph it is known that he was with the ASC in Port Tewfiq at some point.
By April 1916Driver with ASC Horse Transport attached to 9th Army Corps Headquarters.
Circa 16 April 1916Attended Mustapha Reception Hospital near Alexandria. Sent on to 19th General Hospital, Alexandria.
17 April 1916Hospitalised for influenza. Cared for at 19th General Hospital for 4 days. Admission information says:
Age 33.
Length of service 1y 1m
Months with Field Force 1 (perhaps meaning he had been with 9 Army Corps HQ since March)
Days under treatment 4
Received from Reception Hospital Mustapha (Mustapha is a suburb of Alexandria)
Discharged to light duties 21 April 1916 to Base Depot (9 Army or ASC?)
24 Jun 1916Shipped out to France. Attached to 35th Field Ambulance. This RAMC Field Ambulance unit had also served in Gallipoli and was part of the 11th (Northern) Division. In Egypt it was stationed at Sidi Beshr, a suburb of Alexandria some 325 Km north west of Port Tewfiq. It is unclear when between 21 April and 24 June Harry was attached as an ASC driver with the 35th Field Ambulance, i.e. he may have started with them at the time of the move to France.

It is possible that Harry suffered a minor form of shell-shock in 1918, according to his service record, but it was not long-lasting. He drove with the 35th Field Ambulance until after the Armistice.

13 Apr 1919Transferred to Army Reserves at Woolwich Dockyard.
15 Apr 1919Demobilised at Harrowby Camp, Grantham. Reserve Serial number 98569.
After the War, Harry was tested for shell shock that he was said to have suffered during 1918, but there was no supporting documentary evidence. He was also tested for a rodent ulcer which may have reduced his sight in one eye but it was deemed due to an illness and not caused during army service.
VariousListed each year on the Electoral Roll, living at High Street, Bottesford with wife Rose.
27 Feb 1948Took a superannuation payment of £30 from the union – hopefully so he could retire.
1950Listed in the General Membership Register of the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants (i.e. his union)
23 Sep 1950Died at home.
6 Oct 1950The union made a payment of £5, presumably to Rose in respect of Harry’s death.

 

Harry Harby hospital register April 1916 left page

Hospital register right page

As happened to many of the soldiers who served in the Middle East , Harry suffered from dysentery at times and his family believed this affected his health later in life.

Union membership register left page

Union membership right page. The positioning in the third column from the right suggests Harry stopped working due to an accident at work.

See links in the right hand column of this web-page to see other articles about Harry, including the postcards he sent home during the Great War.

This research will continue as there are still some gaps to fill and any new information will be gratefully received.

BP June 2020

 

The following sources of information have been very useful to this item:

Leicestershire Regiment – Have you a Tiger in your family

Ancestry.co.uk war diaries (Subscription)

Port Tewfik postcard site

Find My past (Subscription)

The Long Long Trail

Egyptian Expeditionary Force and Stuart Hadaway’s site

Suez Canal

 

This page was added on 08/06/2020.

No Comments

Start the ball rolling by posting a comment on this page!

Add a comment about this page

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *